Thursday, October 7, 2010

Hearts and Minds

While watching the movie Hearts and Minds I was captivated by the many different voices speaking about the war. There was a variety of point of views and also a lot of footage that brought the Vietnam War to life. The most striking voices to me were the voices of the Vietnamese people who lost family, homes and who have suffered the effects of the war. They spoke with such sadness and spoke their honest opinion and feelings on what was happening. It was completely different from that of the military and political point of view of the United States. It was that despite having lost so much due to the “greed” of the United States (who had no business being there in the first place), the Vietnamese people said that they would never give up, that this loss of lives could not compare to the potential horror the United States would cause if they won. The Vietnamese will continue to fight and that the United States, betrayer of independence and freedom in their eyes, would never win.
One of the men from the government had said that the Vietnamese didn’t respect life as much as the Americans. That life didn’t mean much to them. I was offended by this because it was the opposite to me. It was the United States that didn’t have respect for life, whether it was the lives of the Vietnamese or the lives of the soldiers they kept sending in. The way they spoke about the war and the people involved were distant and cold. The president, the politicians and some citizens would speak in such a manner that didn’t convey to humanity at all.
The way the director places the scenes together helps show a more fleshed out story of the same events. As the bombs dropped by the airplane pilots and the scene of its destruction on the grounds are the most obvious. I think he wanted to show a more three-dimensional point of view of what was going on. On the footage of the United States side, there were a lot of holes and uncertainties that couldn’t be explained that sometimes a protest leader or veterans filled in with their opinions. If one side could only see the war from one way, they were forced to acknowledge it from another point of view. One that they may have never cared enough to listen to. As for the scene in the brothel, I think that scene was included because despite being at war on these people land, the U.S. soldiers still ventured to use these women. It showed that even though they were willing to kill women and children in villages, they would still go to prostitutes of the same ethnicity. This scene to me shows dysfunction and reveals a doubled face side to the soldiers staying in Vietnam. That they didn’t completely suffer and perhaps they were not really there in their minds all the time.   
In this film, the ideologies that the United States used during the war were the same used to cover it up. These were the idea of freedom and independence, the idea that the Vietnamese were savages and the ideology of patriotism. To be proud of one’s country meant to serve in the military and being willing to die without question for your country. That the communist were threatening American freedom when in reality it was the United States threatening the freedom of the Vietnamese. That it was okay to kill the Vietnamese because they were of a less developed country, making them savage. It helped make it easier to excuse the massacres carried out every day in Vietnam. These ideologies, warped, help take away any sympathy and remorse from the soldiers so that they were more willing to carry out the orders given to them. They did it to protect their loved ones, to protect their country’s freedom and to make their nation proud by winning. It didn’t matter who they were hurting or for what cause, they simply did it to win. Whoever wasn’t an American was always the enemy.
I believe the images broadcasted in the news served a purpose because they showed what was really going on. It doesn’t matter how gruesome it was, it was still the truth of what was happening. I do acknowledge the fact that it disrespects a lot of people’s privacy and the footage is sometimes used in bad was. But it can still serve to help people to pay attention to what was going on and to the suffering of others. I believe that these images shouldn’t be plastered everywhere, but they shouldn’t be censored either. To censor one side of the story is to make it bias. I would choice to see the pain and horrible things going on in the world and try to do something about it rather than be ignorant and support something that I don’t truly grasp. Being only able to hear one side of the story is never good enough. It is best to understand the whole story before choicing what side to support. Those who don't listen and loudly bark out their opinion, I could never take them seriously.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Denisse - Your sentence: "the ideologies that the United States used during the war were the same used to cover it up" - is so interesting - I'm not sure it's exactly clear yet, but it's really getting at something. You're not the only one who noticed the footage of Westmoreland (a general) talking about the Vietnamese not respecting life - it's a somewhat famous scene for how effectively it's juxtaposed to the Vietnamese child and mother mourning with so much intensity. Racism is often a part of wartime propaganda to make it easier to kill the enemy - but telling people that the other side doesn't value life is particularly insidious, as it makes it seem more justified when it is taken away.

    ReplyDelete